“ Salvatore made the ambiance welcoming and warm! He didn't discriminate my pineapple love on my cheesy slice.. in-fact he embraced it with an extra side! If you want good pizza with a side of spicy personality this is the place for you. All your wildest dreams will come true ”

“ The pizza options here are overwhelming in a good way! I have tried the pepperoni and sausage Sicilian and the Hawaiian, which were all amazing. The staff is very friendly and a service is quick. they have a small section for outdoor seating which is really nice in the summer when the weather is warm. I had the pleasure of meeting Tony himself and he shared a slice of his favorite pizza with me. This pizza place isn't the nearest one to me, but it definitely is worth the walk! ”

“ My first NYC pizza was the best NYC pizza. Great vibes in here too. Go get em! The buffalo chicken smacks ”

“ Best pizzeria in town BY FAR. Not just a pizzeria but in my opinion a 5 star Italian restaurant. I had the scallops -- AMAZING, the gelato -- tasted like Italia for real. My group of friends each had a different dish & everything, the meat dishes, pasta dishes, side dishes, salad, the breads, all Micheline quality. Don't even get me started with the pizza. All pies all styles from the sicilian to the classic slice I give a 12 out of 10! Vegan options as well this place is THE BEST. Let me not forget the service & atmospher -- on point!! P.S Their homemade desserts are a must try! ”

“ The pizza and the welcoming vibe are both worth coming back for!! I felt comfortable lingering and staff, as well customers, were happy to suggest items from the menu and often had a memory associated with it. ”

“ Used to come as a family to Tony's pizzeria as a child when we lived in this area . Came by recently to have pizza, Food tasted great , cooked well . Clean atmosphere indoor and also outdoor dining . Quick service of food . Variety of pizza , ice cream , soda , cakes and cookies and other foods variety ”

“ I love their pizza; it is typical New York pizza. I love their ingredients; I usually order cheese or a pizza roll. Both are really good! The chicken rolls have sesame seeds; I would prefer it if they didn't, but they are still delicious. The staff are super lovely every single time I've ordered for takeout and in person. The ambiance here is very welcoming, and the workers are friendly and speak to customers; I've never had a bad encounter here. ”

“ So I was on Knickerbocker Avenue this Easter Sunday 4/9/23 around 6:pm and I just wasn't feeling all that Spanish food today I was actually craving Italian and believe it or not there's an Italian cook in this kitchen !!! This is a real deal Still Italian owned & operated Pizzeria and restaurant..... I was craving penny à la vodka and the slice, which both were delicious.... My vodka sauce was perfect with a lil chunky tomato's and with a lil prosciutto chopped up nice & creamy & my pasta is cooked to perfection al dente !! They give you a lil twisted garlic bread with melted cheese in the middle which did its job helping me scoop all that yummy sauce out from my plate !!! Move over garlic knots & Italian bread & hello twisty hot garlic cheesy stick !!! Also they served me a lil Indy garden salad with Italian dressing also very good ... The slice I choose was their margarita with fresh mozzarella and basil, the crust was super thin & crispy & the sauce & fresh mozzarella was delicious !!! Sorry for no picture but the slice had no chance I was starving !!! Lol The restaurant is very clean with plenty of seating and the counter servers we're very polite & fast .. They are extremely busy over here with pizza alone for a holiday they had over 15 different kinds of fresh pies to go by the slice .... Deserts they definitely got ya covered over here; take a look, gelato, numerous cake slices, as well as whole cakes, big selection to please everyone !! Definitely coming back when in the area and definitely telling my co workers about this place ... By the way that pasta dish with the twisty bread & the side salad with a slice and a can soda $ 20 bucks well worth it !! A must try !!! Thanks, Greg D / NYCDOT EMERGENCY JOLT TASK TEAM. ”

“ Seriously awesome food. The other day we put in an order for rice balls with vodka sauce, pesto sauce, and tomato sauce on top. We got the upside down pie and the Caesar salad as an extra thing. Everything was excellent. i ordered the greek salad today for lunch. it was fantastic. ”